Most companies never audit their software spend because it sounds like a project. It doesn’t have to be. You need three exports, one spreadsheet and an afternoon without meetings. Here is the method.
1. Build the list from the money, not from memory
Ask people which tools they use and you get the tools they like. Ask the ledger and you get the tools you pay for. Start with the ledger.
- Export the last twelve months of card and bank transactions from your expense or accounting system.
- Filter for recurring charges. Software subscriptions repeat on the same day each month or year, usually for the same amount.
- Add any annual invoices paid by transfer. These are the ones most often forgotten, because they appear once a year.
Put one row per tool in a sheet with these columns: tool, owner, billing (monthly or annual), seats paid for, monthly cost, renewal date.
If a charge has no obvious owner, write “unknown”. An unknown owner is itself a finding.
2. Count the people, not the seats
For each tool, open its admin panel and note how many seats you pay for and how many people logged in during the last 30 or 90 days. Most business tools show this on a members or billing page.
The gap between those two numbers is the first saving, and it is the safest one: removing a seat nobody uses changes nothing for anyone.
A useful rule of thumb is to treat a tool as under-used when fewer than four in five paid seats are active. It is a threshold, not a law. Adjust it for seasonal teams.
3. Sort every line into one of five buckets
With cost and usage on one sheet, each tool falls into one bucket:
| Bucket | When it applies | What you do |
|---|---|---|
| Cut | Paid seats, nobody active | Cancel at the next renewal |
| Rightsize | Some seats idle, or paying monthly where annual is cheaper | Remove seats or switch billing |
| Consolidate | Two tools doing the same job | Keep the one more people use |
| Build | A simple tool with a large bill | Price an internal replacement |
| Keep | Used, priced fairly, hard to replace | Leave it alone |
Consolidation is where the bigger numbers usually hide. Two chat tools, two video tools, a project tracker per department: each team chose sensibly on its own, and the company pays twice.
For annual billing, check the vendor’s pricing page. Many tools list a discount for paying yearly. A 17% discount on a $12 seat is about $2 a seat a month; across 50 seats that is around $1,200 a year for changing one setting. Only switch tools you are confident you will keep for the year.
4. Do the arithmetic, then write it down
For each line that is not “keep”, write the monthly saving next to it and the date you can act on it (often the renewal date). Sum the column. That number, and the list behind it, is the audit.
Two habits keep it useful:
- Name an owner for every tool. Owners notice idle seats; nobody else does.
- Diary the renewals. Most savings can only be taken at renewal. Put each date in a calendar a month ahead.
What the afternoon will not tell you
This method finds waste. It does not tell you whether a tool is worth its price to the people using it. Before cutting anything that people actively use, ask them what they would lose. Sometimes the expensive tool is the cheapest way to get the job done.
If you would rather not build the sheet by hand, the analyzer linked below runs the same buckets on the tools you enter.